A Life Well Played: The Definitive Story of Lou Carnesecca

Lou Carnesecca, born Luigi P. Carnesecca on January 5, 1925, was raised in East Harlem by Italian immigrant parents, Alfred and Adele. His father, Alfred, dreamed of his son becoming a doctor, often encouraging him with the phrase, “Be a doctor. Be a somebody.” However, Lou’s journey took a different path, one that left an indelible mark on college basketball history.

Early Education and College Choices

Carnesecca initially enrolled at Fordham University in a pre-med course, attempting to fulfill his father’s wishes. Yet, his passion for sports ultimately led him to transfer to St. John’s University. Though he did not play basketball for the varsity team, he contributed as a player in the university’s baseball program under the legendary coach Frank McGuire. Lou’s baseball talent took the team to the College World Series in 1949, but his heart was set on basketball.

Under McGuire’s mentorship, Lou honed his coaching instincts by scouting players, refereeing scrimmages, and analyzing opposing teams. He quickly realized that coaching was his true calling and began his career as a basketball coach at St. Ann’s Academy.

Coaching Career and Accomplishments

In 1965, Carnesecca became the head basketball coach at St. John’s University, succeeding Joe Lapchick. Over his 24-year tenure, Lou led his teams, known then as the Redmen, to 526 wins against 200 losses. His coaching prowess reached its zenith during the 1984-85 season, when his team, led by Chris Mullin, achieved a 31-4 record and a Final Four appearance.

Lou’s influence extended beyond victories. He mentored over a dozen players who went on to NBA and ABA careers, including Mark Jackson, Jayson Williams, and the late Malik Sealy. In recognition of his remarkable contributions, he was inducted into the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame in 1992, shortly before retiring.

Trials and Triumphs

Carnesecca briefly stepped away from college basketball to coach the ABA’s New York Nets from 1970 to 1973. Despite initial success with star player Rick Barry, Lou found professional coaching unfulfilling. After parting ways with the Nets, he returned to St. John’s, where his most significant achievements awaited.

A colorful figure, Lou was known for his raspy voice, passionate demeanor, and the iconic sweaters he wore during games—a symbol of his superstition and humor. His humility and sense of gratitude remained evident throughout his career, often attributing his success to his players rather than his coaching.

Survivors and Legacy

Lou Carnesecca is survived by his wife of 73 years, Mary, and their daughter, Enes. His influence continues to be felt in the basketball world, not just for his coaching success but for the values he exemplified: dedication, humility, and an unyielding love for the game.

Pros and Cons of Lou’s Career for College Basketball

Pros:

Lou’s career elevated the reputation of college basketball, particularly at St. John’s. His mentorship developed some of the sport’s brightest talents, and his charismatic leadership helped bring mainstream attention to the Big East Conference.

Cons:

Lou’s insistence on tradition, including his initial resistance to the formation of the Big East, reflected a reluctance to embrace changes that ultimately shaped the modern college basketball landscape.

A Legacy of Passion, Progress, and Tradition in College Basketball

Lou Carnesecca’s legacy elevated college basketball’s prominence, fostered mentorship, yet challenged adaptability—highlighting passion’s impact on tradition and progress.

Reflecting On The Life of Lou Carnesecca

Lou Carnesecca’s story is a testament to the importance of pursuing one’s passion while maintaining balance in life. His career, filled with triumphs and trials, serves as an example of how embracing one’s calling can lead to extraordinary accomplishments. Let his legacy inspire readers to value work-life balance and dedicate themselves to their passions without compromising their principles.

No Time for a Timeout

When asked in 2021 by then-Post columnist Ian O’Connor whether he spent time pondering his own mortality, Carnesecca said:

“I pray to the Blessed Mother that she gives me the strength and courage to handle what’s coming. Of course, it goes back to your faith, you know? And it’s out of my hands. I can’t call timeout.”